To understand the Trivium, we must first understand at least a little bit about Christian Philosophy. St. Thomas Aquinas explained that there are four divisions of philosophy, the first of which is Rational Philosophy, or the art and science of Reasoning, on which the other divisions depend.
Classical education is not centered about the art of Reasoning, which is the “instrument” (Grk. organon) of human wisdom-seeking. Everything proceeds from and revolves around the art and science of Reasoning, which no schools today neglect or only pretend to teach. As we find in other subjects, they teach overly-simplified courses of their own making called “Logic” or “Dialectic”, using modern textbooks designed for modern school objectives, but the students’ knowledge is easily proven false by their inability to understand Aristotle’s works. Blessed John Henry Newman criticized these artificial modern studies and said, rightly, that “to think correctly, we must think like Aristotle.”
The doctrine of Rational Philosophy is learned in Aristotle’s Organon, which takes for granted the knowledge of classical Grammar. Thus, to study Reasoning, it is necessary to first study classical Grammar, through which ideas, in all their complexity, can be accurately named. If the course in Grammar provided to the student does not satisfy the objectives of classical Grammar as understood by the philosophers, it will not prepare them to progress in the pursuit of Wisdom.
For example, when we move into the study of Reasoning, we find that Aristotle requires the following understanding of a Noun:
“A noun is a sound significant from compact, without time, of which no part taken separately is significant.”
Only a Grammar program that prepares a student to understand language in this way can be called a “classical” Grammar program. This is why signing up for a Latin course doesn’t mean that a student is actually receiving true, classical education. What is needed is not “conversational” Latin, but a systematic Grammar course that proves true and helpful when we seek to move on to higher studies. We are the only program that offers classical Grammar courses of this quality.
As in Reasoning and Grammar, many modern publishers and schools are advertising books and courses under the name of “Rhetoric” that have nothing to do with the true, classical art spoken of by the ancients. Aristotle explains that “Rhetoric is the counterpart to Reasoning” in his teaching because rhetoric is required for the fulfillment of a virtuous life explained in Aristotle’s Ethics:
“Man is a social animal, and the happy man has need of friends.”
The true art of Rhetoric is the means by which a man, having ordered his own thoughts and actions rightly, seeks to lead other men to join him in his good works. However, a wise man understands that persuasion is not in his power and the true test of one’s rhetorical expertise is not whether he persuades other men, but whether he attempts to do so as effectively as is possible. This is why Aristotle says not that Rhetoric is the “art of persuasion”, as modern teachers falsely say, but the art by which man seeks to discover “all of the available means of persuasion”.
Further, when we learn that these means of persuasion are not matters of speaking or writing, but reach to man’s reputation (ethos), reasoning skills (logos) and understanding of human passions (pathos), we see that writing better essays and learning to speak in front of an audience have nothing to do with true, classical Rhetoric.
Understanding man’s nature and end, the necessity of the Trivium becomes clear. Upon these three arts–Grammar, Reasoning and Rhetoric–depend all higher studies in the Quadrivium, in Philosophy and in Theology. If the foundation is not rightly laid, the house that needs to be built cannot be built upon it.